Skip to content
Reference Lap

Compare drivers

Two drivers over the grands prix they both started in a season. Only rounds in the same car compare the drivers with the car taken out; for the rest, the model's rating difference is the estimate separate from the car, with its uncertainty.

Swap

Changing the season keeps the drivers when both raced that season; otherwise it picks a pairing.

Head-to-head

MAGKevin MagnussenvsHULNico Hülkenberg· 22 shared races, 22 as teammates

Teammates in every shared race: the same car, so this is the cleanest comparison.

MAG first.
MeasureMAG–HUL
Weekends together22
Qualifying ahead7–15
Race ahead, both classified8–10
Race ahead, finish order (a DNF counts as behind)9–13
Sprint ahead, finish order4–2
Points (grand prix and shared sprints)3–9
DNFs3–1
Average finish vs the model's expected finish before the race, over the shared races, retirements included; gains in places per race, + = better than expected.
DriverRacesAvg finishAvg expectedVs model, shared racesSeason, all races ± SE
MAGK. Magnussen2215.614.51.06 places worse than the model expected1.06 places worse than the model expected ± 0.59
HULN. Hülkenberg2214.513.60.90 places worse than the model expected0.90 places worse than the model expected ± 0.65

Measured against the model, which already includes each driver's rating and car: a surprise, not a comparison of the drivers. Avg finish is over the races with an expectation.

Rating difference by round

Kevin Magnussen's rating minus Nico Hülkenberg's, where each rating is the estimated pace vs the mean driver (model). Negative (higher on the chart) = MAG estimated faster; the band is ±1 sd. A difference within about 1 sd is not a clear difference.

In rounds as teammates the sd uses the model's covariance of the two ratings (teammates' estimates are linked).

Round 22: race +0.138% ± 0.115 (HUL estimated faster), qualifying +0.285% ± 0.093 (HUL estimated faster).

race rating: MAG − HUL
Data table
race rating difference MAG − HUL, % (± sd).
RoundMAG − HUL
R10.066 ± 0.313
R20.034 ± 0.221
R3-0.022 ± 0.188
R4-0.049 ± 0.159
R5-0.055 ± 0.149
R6-0.064 ± 0.142
R7-0.069 ± 0.138
R8-0.012 ± 0.134
R90.006 ± 0.125
R100.074 ± 0.130
R110.143 ± 0.128
R120.133 ± 0.123
R130.088 ± 0.122
R140.103 ± 0.121
R150.105 ± 0.121
R160.024 ± 0.120
R170.151 ± 0.117
R180.170 ± 0.113
R190.188 ± 0.114
R200.156 ± 0.109
R210.128 ± 0.114
R220.138 ± 0.115
qualifying rating: MAG − HUL
Data table
qualifying rating difference MAG − HUL, % (± sd).
RoundMAG − HUL
R10.395 ± 0.188
R20.322 ± 0.150
R30.471 ± 0.133
R40.366 ± 0.115
R50.255 ± 0.110
R60.204 ± 0.106
R70.250 ± 0.104
R80.316 ± 0.105
R90.339 ± 0.098
R100.395 ± 0.102
R110.440 ± 0.100
R120.539 ± 0.102
R130.489 ± 0.100
R140.469 ± 0.099
R150.423 ± 0.100
R160.318 ± 0.099
R170.457 ± 0.097
R180.391 ± 0.092
R190.378 ± 0.093
R200.324 ± 0.089
R210.278 ± 0.092
R220.285 ± 0.093
Differences by round, with the sd used
RoundCarsRace ± sdQuali ± sdsd
R1same car+0.066% ± 0.313+0.395% ± 0.188with covariance
R2same car+0.034% ± 0.221+0.322% ± 0.150with covariance
R3same car−0.022% ± 0.188+0.471% ± 0.133with covariance
R4same car−0.049% ± 0.159+0.366% ± 0.115with covariance
R5same car−0.055% ± 0.149+0.255% ± 0.110with covariance
R6same car−0.064% ± 0.142+0.204% ± 0.106with covariance
R7same car−0.069% ± 0.138+0.250% ± 0.104with covariance
R8same car−0.012% ± 0.134+0.316% ± 0.105with covariance
R9same car+0.006% ± 0.125+0.339% ± 0.098with covariance
R10same car+0.074% ± 0.130+0.395% ± 0.102with covariance
R11same car+0.143% ± 0.128+0.440% ± 0.100with covariance
R12same car+0.133% ± 0.123+0.539% ± 0.102with covariance
R13same car+0.088% ± 0.122+0.489% ± 0.100with covariance
R14same car+0.103% ± 0.121+0.469% ± 0.099with covariance
R15same car+0.105% ± 0.121+0.423% ± 0.100with covariance
R16same car+0.024% ± 0.120+0.318% ± 0.099with covariance
R17same car+0.151% ± 0.117+0.457% ± 0.097with covariance
R18same car+0.170% ± 0.113+0.391% ± 0.092with covariance
R19same car+0.188% ± 0.114+0.378% ± 0.093with covariance
R20same car+0.156% ± 0.109+0.324% ± 0.089with covariance
R21same car+0.128% ± 0.114+0.278% ± 0.092with covariance
R22same car+0.138% ± 0.115+0.285% ± 0.093with covariance

Shared races

Every grand prix both started. “Different cars” rows compare cars as much as drivers.
RoundCarsMAG qualiHUL qualiMAG finishHUL finishAheadMAG vs modelHUL vs model
R1same car1710P13P15MAG0.9 places better than the model expected2.5 places worse than the model expected
R2same car1311P10P12MAG3.9 places better than the model expected0.9 places better than the model expected
R3same car1410P17P7HUL3.8 places worse than the model expected5.4 places better than the model expected
R4same car1817P13P17MAG0.4 places better than the model expected2.9 places worse than the model expected
R5same car412P10P15MAG0.6 places better than the model expected2.0 places worse than the model expected
R6same car1718P19P17HUL5.4 places worse than the model expected2.9 places worse than the model expected
R7same car178P18P15HUL3.7 places worse than the model expected2.1 places worse than the model expected
R8same car142P17P15HUL3.6 places worse than the model expected3.1 places worse than the model expected
R9same car198P18DNF · UnknownMAG3.8 places worse than the model expected8.5 places worse than the model expected
R10same car1911DNF · UnknownP13HUL4.3 places worse than the model expected0.2 places better than the model expected
R11same car1910P17P14HUL1.5 places worse than the model expected0.5 places worse than the model expected
R12same car1320P15P18MAG0.7 places better than the model expected2.9 places worse than the model expected
R13same car1815P16P12HUL0.1 places better than the model expected2.7 places better than the model expected
R14same car1913P18P17HUL2.0 places worse than the model expected2.4 places worse than the model expected
R15same car69P10P13MAG3.3 places better than the model expected0.4 places better than the model expected
R16same car1518P15P14HUL0.3 places worse than the model expected0.9 places better than the model expected
R17same car1915P14P16MAG1.8 places better than the model expected1.8 places worse than the model expected
R18same car1416P14P11HUL1.9 places better than the model expected4.0 places better than the model expected
R19same car1712DNF · IncidentP13HUL3.0 places worse than the model expected1.2 places better than the model expected
R20same car1411DNF · UnknownP12HUL2.7 places worse than the model expected2.1 places better than the model expected
R21same car913P13P19MAG1.9 places better than the model expected4.0 places worse than the model expected
R22same car178P20P15HUL4.5 places worse than the model expected1.8 places worse than the model expected

Ahead: by finishing order (a retirement counts as behind). Kevin Magnussen · Nico Hülkenberg