Skip to content
Reference Lap

Compare drivers

Two drivers over the grands prix they both started in a season. Only rounds in the same car compare the drivers with the car taken out; for the rest, the model's rating difference is the estimate separate from the car, with its uncertainty.

Swap

Changing the season keeps the drivers when both raced that season; otherwise it picks a pairing.

Head-to-head

HULNico HülkenbergvsBEAOliver Bearman· 3 shared races, 2 as teammates

Partly different cars. Nico Hülkenberg and Oliver Bearman were teammates in 2 of 3 shared races. In round 2 they drove different cars; the teammate-only head-to-head leaves those out.

HUL first.
MeasureHUL–BEA, all shared racesAs teammates only
Weekends together32
Qualifying ahead0–30–2
Race ahead, both classified0–20–1
Race ahead, finish order (a DNF counts as behind)0–30–2
Sprint ahead, finish order0–10–1
Points (grand prix and shared sprints)1–70–1
DNFs1–01–0
Average finish vs the model's expected finish before the race, over the shared races, retirements included; gains in places per race, + = better than expected.
DriverRacesAvg finishAvg expectedVs model, shared racesSeason, all races ± SE
HULN. Hülkenberg313.712.90.75 places worse than the model expected0.68 places better than the model expected ± 0.70
BEAO. Bearman39.712.32.60 places better than the model expected2.60 places better than the model expected ± 0.77

Measured against the model, which already includes each driver's rating and car: a surprise, not a comparison of the drivers. Avg finish is over the races with an expectation.

Rating difference by round

Nico Hülkenberg's rating minus Oliver Bearman's, where each rating is the estimated pace vs the mean driver (model). Negative (higher on the chart) = HUL estimated faster; the band is ±1 sd. A difference within about 1 sd is not a clear difference.

In rounds as teammates the sd uses the model's covariance of the two ratings (teammates' estimates are linked). In rounds in different teams the two sds are combined as if independent, an approximation.

Round 21: race −0.092% ± 0.131 (not a clear difference), qualifying −0.152% ± 0.127 (HUL estimated faster).

race rating: HUL − BEA
Data table
race rating difference HUL − BEA, % (± sd).
RoundHUL − BEA
R2-0.157 ± 0.263
R17-0.218 ± 0.164
R21-0.092 ± 0.131
qualifying rating: HUL − BEA
Data table
qualifying rating difference HUL − BEA, % (± sd).
RoundHUL − BEA
R2-0.334 ± 0.244
R17-0.163 ± 0.154
R21-0.152 ± 0.127
Differences by round, with the sd used
RoundCarsRace ± sdQuali ± sdsd
R2different cars−0.157% ± 0.263−0.334% ± 0.244independent (approx.)
R17same car−0.218% ± 0.164−0.163% ± 0.154with covariance
R21same car−0.092% ± 0.131−0.152% ± 0.127with covariance

Shared races

Every grand prix both started. “Different cars” rows compare cars as much as drivers.
RoundCarsHUL qualiBEA qualiHUL finishBEA finishAheadHUL vs modelBEA vs model
R2different carsHUL: Haas F1 Team; BEA: Ferrari.1511P10P7BEA3.5 places better than the model expected3.5 places better than the model expected
R17same car1311P11P10BEA1.5 places better than the model expected3.3 places better than the model expected
R21same car1917DSQP12BEA7.2 places worse than the model expected1.1 places better than the model expected

Ahead: by finishing order (a retirement counts as behind). Nico Hülkenberg · Oliver Bearman